The Difference Between Honoring Your Gut and Living in Hypervigilance
Welcome to Mamahood After Trauma, a space created to support mothers as they heal from trauma, break generational cycles, and discover healthier ways of showing up for themselves and their families. Here, you’ll find honest conversations, practical tools, and encouragement to remind you that healing is possible, one step at a time.

Introduction
When Tricia Youngs’ first pregnancy appeared to be progressing normally, her scans and prenatal tests brought reassuring news. But at five and a half months, a final sonogram revealed devastating complications. Her baby had only two chambers in his heart, along with hydrocephalus. Youngs and her husband were faced with an unimaginable decision. They left the hospital without their son and went straight to the undertaker.
“It was horrible,” she recalled. “The grief was overwhelming.”
Years later, after becoming a mother to a daughter, Youngs discovered that grief and past trauma don't simply disappear. Instead, they can resurface in unexpected ways, especially through the everyday experiences of parenting. Questions about safety, independence, boundaries, and trust can become much more complicated when viewed through the lens of past experiences. Youngs is a licensed mental health counselor and transformational coach who has spent nearly three decades working with clients. However, her understanding of trauma began long before her professional career. She describes her own life as containing “many slices of trauma” and shares that she had already done significant healing before becoming a mother. But motherhood brought new opportunities for those old wounds to surface.
Table of Contents
A Rule for the Neighbor's House
When the Body Remembers Before the Mind
The Grief Behind the Hypervigilance
Learning to Recognize the Difference Between Fear and Intuition

A Rule for the Neighbor's House
During a later pregnancy, Youngs experienced another difficult season when she lost her job after her employer learned she was expecting. She spent much of her pregnancy in quieter surroundings, visiting bookstores, attending Bible studies, and participating in 12-step meetings. Yet the anxiety surrounding her previous pregnancy loss remained.
Youngs also carried a history of sexual abuse, emotional neglect, and experiences in which she had not been adequately protected. When she became a mother, she became increasingly aware of how easily those experiences could influence her desire to protect her daughter from every possible danger.
“I didn’t want to pass my stuff on to my daughter,” she explained.
In their neighborhood, there was one particular father who triggered an internal alarm for Youngs. She didn't have any concrete evidence that he posed a danger. She simply felt uneasy. Rather than allowing that fear to dictate every aspect of her daughter's social life, she established a specific boundary. If her daughter went to that family's house to play, one parent would accompany her and keep an eye on the children from a distance. She didn't forbid the playdates or accuse the neighbor of anything. She recognized that his daughter had done nothing wrong and wanted to avoid allowing her own fears to affect an innocent friendship. Instead, she established a boundary that allowed her daughter to enjoy time with her friends while giving herself some peace of mind.
“I think I was actually honoring my intuition,” she reflected.
This distinction is important. Youngs wasn't suggesting that every feeling of fear should automatically be trusted, nor that every concern should be dismissed as trauma. Instead, she demonstrated the importance of recognizing our internal responses and learning how to respond to them thoughtfully. Our past experiences can make us more sensitive to potential danger, but that doesn't mean we have to let fear control our decisions.
When the Body Remembers Before the Mind
Youngs explained that hypervigilance often occurs when our bodies enter a state of heightened alertness. Our fight, flight, freeze, or fawn response can take over, making it difficult to think clearly or respond calmly. In those moments, everything can feel urgent. Even an ordinary situation can suddenly seem threatening. One question Youngs encourages people to ask themselves when experiencing an intense emotional reaction is simple:
How old do I feel right now?
Sometimes, our reactions are connected to experiences from an earlier season of life. A situation in the present can trigger memories, emotions, or fears that we haven't fully processed. For example, a child's reaching a particular age can bring up difficult memories for a parent who experienced neglect, abuse, or a lack of protection at that same age. Without realizing it, the parent may begin responding to their child's experiences through the lens of their own childhood.
Youngs describes this pattern with the phrase “hysterical is historical.” In other words, sometimes our reactions are bigger than the situation in front of us because they are connected to something that happened in the past. She shared the example of a client whose wife encouraged him to seek therapy because he wouldn't allow their children to ride their bikes very far from home. At first, his rules seemed like excessive caution. However, through therapy, they discovered that his anxiety was connected to an accident from his childhood. His brother had been seriously injured while he was supposed to be watching him.
He had carried that guilt with him into adulthood, unknowingly allowing the experience to influence how he parented his own children. He wanted to protect them from experiencing anything similar. As he began working through that childhood memory, his anxiety gradually decreased. His children were eventually given more freedom to explore their surroundings.
Before therapy, they could only ride their bikes as far as the next driveway. Eventually, they were able to ride all the way to the street sign. The circumstances hadn't necessarily changed. What changed was his understanding of where his fear was coming from.
The Grief Behind the Hypervigilance
For Youngs, the loss of her first baby remained an important part of her story when she became pregnant again. Although she tried to make her subsequent pregnancy as peaceful and encouraging as possible, she couldn't simply erase the anxiety left behind by her previous experience. Pregnancy after loss can bring a complicated mixture of emotions. There can be excitement and hope, but also fear, uncertainty, and the constant desire for reassurance.
Her experiences also gave her a deeper understanding of grief, trauma, and the emotional challenges that can accompany motherhood. Today, she brings both her professional knowledge and personal experiences into her work with others. Youngs is also the author of Rescued: Hope for the Shattered Heart and Soul, a book that combines her personal journey with encouragement and guidance for those navigating trauma, whether their own or someone else's. Her approach to parenting and healing isn't about dismissing fear or automatically obeying every internal alarm. It's about learning to recognize what is happening beneath the surface. In her own experience, she established a boundary that allowed her daughter to maintain friendships without ignoring her concerns. With her client, she helped uncover how an unresolved childhood experience had shaped his parenting decisions. Both situations demonstrate how important it is to understand the connection between our past and our present.
Learning to Recognize the Difference Between Fear and Intuition
For mothers who struggle to distinguish between a genuine concern and a fear rooted in past trauma, Youngs offered an important reminder: the most worrying possibility isn't always the most likely one. Children will inevitably encounter risks as they grow. However, many of the worst-case scenarios parents imagine never actually happen.
When anxiety becomes a constant presence in the home, it can also begin to influence how children see the world. A parent's fears can unintentionally become part of a child's everyday experience, limiting their confidence and freedom.
Youngs encourages mothers to make space for activities that support their emotional and physical well-being. Whether that looks like movement, journaling, therapy, or listening to music that lifts their spirits, taking time to care for themselves matters.
Self-care doesn't mean every wound will suddenly disappear. It means recognizing that motherhood can bring old wounds to the surface and giving ourselves the opportunity to address them. Youngs' journey reminds us that becoming a mother doesn't mean leaving our past behind. Sometimes, motherhood brings experiences and emotions to the surface that we thought we had already worked through. The goal isn't to become a parent who never feels afraid. It's to become a parent who can recognize where that fear is coming from, respond with wisdom, and avoid allowing yesterday's experiences to dictate today's decisions. Healing is not about ignoring the alarms within us. It's about learning which ones require our attention and which ones belong to a chapter of our lives that we no longer have to live in.

Resources
Emily Cleghorn’s Free Quiz: “Find Your Next Step to Calm and Healing”.
Check out Tricia's Instagram here: https://www.instagram.com/triciayoungs/?hl=en
Check out Tricia's Website here: https://www.triciayoungs.com/
If you’re a mama healing from trauma and seeking a new way forward, remember: You deserve support, your child deserves joy, and together, you can break cycles and build a brighter future.



Comments